Tuesday, January 10, 2012
Island Time
Here, I eye my watch (or the bottom corner of my screen) all day long. When new email pings in, I jump to determine whether I need to respond right away. I am constantly monitoring Z, to insure that he is making progress in his (eclectic) homeschool assignment du jour. I am trying to fit my own work in around the edges here (which is probably backwards). I figure my job will be there for awhile, but Z will grow up and I don't want to miss these moments. Once the other kids arrive home from school, we start the slog through the day's homework, packing their school things away. Then, off to lessons, sports, or other commitments. Finally, we have hungry children to feed, dirty children to clean, dirty clothing to clean, fold, and pack away. Then, we have tired children to convince to bed. Thus, only leaving a house to clean (not often), and the various other life forms that depend on us (dog, plants, yard, etc.). Don't get me wrong - I love it all, but there is always a sense of immediacy. This doesn't really suit my type B personality.
In the Bahamas, the stress is different. My watch is less important - there, it is the weather. I watch prevailing winds, temperatures, and storms to try to fit in all of our activities around the (mostly) unpredictable whims of the weather. I worry about keeping track of our children and other people's children (my students). I count heads a lot and try to warn people about risks that are new to them.
In the Bahamas, parenting is different. I don't cook or do dishes. I have a different sense of clean and dirty for the kids' clothing (and my own, frankly). The kids are busy all day exploring, creating, learning, and living - no homework drudgery. The kids feed off of the playful energy of the students. The students feed off of the curiosity and unbridled enthusiasm of the kids. In addition to J watching the children, we have a dedicated helper keeping them from killing themselves or each other. The kids are so exhausted at night that, for the most part, they pass out once their heads hit the pillow.
In the Bahamas, teaching is different. The class is so compact that the students have a constant sense of urgency - no one gets tired of the day-to-day schedule. Everything is new and different, which makes it more salient. The buddy system in the water and their trepidation at the unknown (will there be sharks? stingrays? are the currents strong or waves rough?) makes them operate naturally as a team. We are released from the drama that is associated with our relationships with people out of class. We are released from the constant pull of electronic communication.
In the Bahamas, introverted folks like me interact regularly with new and interesting people from all over. And, with the tropical setting and the communal meals - it is easier to get to know people than I find it here.
I returned home to a cold, gray and rainy world. The kids are sluggish getting ready for school and balk at working on homework. I know that they are having the same trouble re-adjusting. How to balance providing compassion for this challenge and the need to make it happen?
Tuesday, December 13, 2011
Enabler.
This year, one of my students has, thus far, failed to complete a single piece of this preparation on their own. His mother has been the main point person on every piece of paperwork, documentation, and meeting. His mother has finished the papers, sent the emails, contacted me, and sent apologies.
What will this child do when he gets his first job? Will she serve as a go-between for his boss? Will she wake him up so he can get to work on time?
Kid. You are in your 20s. You are a college student. You want to live "independently". With that kind of power comes responsibility.
Kid. It is time to buck up, grow up, and do the right thing.
Mom. It is time to back off, let your kid face his own consequences, and force your kid to grow up.
I hope that I am never this mom and that my child is never this child.
Thursday, December 8, 2011
Dear Abby thinks "Worst First"
http://www.uexpress.com/printable/print.html?uc_full_date=20111208&uc_comic=da
Essentially, her answer is never, because something could happen.
Here is my response...
Dear Abby,
On 8 December, you responded to a working mom that wanted to know at what age a child can be left in the house alone. You responded “I don’t think children should be left alone if there is any alternative…” because “Too many things can go wrong…” This is a classic example of what Lenore Skenazy (www.freerangekids.com) refers to as “worst-first” thinking. Because of rare tragic things that could happen, we will handicap our children’s ability to gain from the many positives associated with this kind of independence. Further, we will handicap this parent’s finances and their ability to shop alone for brief periods of time.
Can you really not imagine any age where a child is capable of being left alone in their home? Not at 8? Or 11? Or 14? Or 17? How is it that these children will learn to be capable adults if they don’t get to practice gaining increments of independence under the (sometimes remote) supervision of their parents or guardians? Is this why, as a professor, I see college students today that are incapable of facing the regular bumps and glitches of daily life without calling on their parents to fix their problems for them?
Perhaps instead of “never”, we can look for indicators that a child is capable of short time periods home alone. In that each child develops differently, the right age for gaining responsibility and freedom will be different. Here is one article highlighting the signs of readiness: http://kidshealth.org/parent/firstaid_safe/home/home_alone.html. After experimenting with leaving them home during short errands, children can gain confidence and earn additional freedoms. Practice can help children gain confidence in solving their own problems on the road to becoming capable adults.
Instead of infantilizing our children due to remote risks, we need to empower them. If you will recall, just a few decades ago, we did that very thing. I was a latch-key kid at nine and babysitting at 11. In the 70’s, this was regular practice. Before you argue that the world was safer then, note that the crime statistics show that life is safer today than it has been since 1970 or earlier. In that time on my own, I learned how to feed myself when I was hungry, how to clean up after myself, how to take care of others, who to call when you need help, and I developed the confidence that I could take care of myself. That experience was invaluable.
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
But, what about the controversy?
For example, the children are taught unequivocally that the earth is round.
There are a lot of people that believe, instead, that the earth is flat. Isn't it unfair that their viewpoint is being treated with such disdain? Why is it that we have this value judgment in place where we will teach one set of beliefs and not the other? It is culturocentric for us to presume to teach only one side of this controversial topic.
Where are the discussions about the cultures that dissent on this issue? Where are the alternative map views?
It is all about giving fair time to different perspectives. Isn't it?
Thursday, October 13, 2011
The most exciting day of school.
- Our eight-year-old taking on college kids in chess.
- Our six-year-old playing with sea creatures under a microscope.
- All three boys fishing on a boat, learning to identify fish, types of bait, how boats and waves move, how wind interacts with waves, tides, and how to work together toward a common goal.
- Hiking in the forest and trying to catch bugs.
- Doing long, hard, challenging workouts for months on end until you can earn the privilege of testing for the your next belt in your martial arts.
- Disassembling furniture, and trying to put it back together again.
- Finding a book in the library that makes them want to tuck in and read all afternoon.
- Determining whether or not you want an item based on how many weeks allowance it would cost.
- Negotiating deals and calculating costs in monopoly.
- Building Lego robots, and programming them.
- Talking about different ways of viewing the world and our culture.
- Reading Richard Dawkins new book, and asking Professor Dawkins a question about it.
- Holding a live hummingbird at the hummingbird festival.
- Going to a Rennaissance Fair.
- Practicing piano for weekly lessons - this week... "Hedwig's Theme"!
- Learning about their uncle's sculpture.
- Picking out a recipe and cooking dinner.
- Going to an art gallery.
- Playing with dry ice.
- Building and lighting a fire.
Self motivation - they were learning because they were personally invested in learning something.
Determination - they were teaching themselves to stick with something, even when it is hard.
Pushing the bounds of their knowledge and know-how - they were stretching themselves in new and different ways.
Responsibility - they were empowered to try something out, even at the risk of minor injury, to learn to take care of themselves and make good choices.
These are the features that we should be looking for in quality, high gain schoolwork. Not more, just more interesting. While all schoolwork can't do all of this, all school work should do some of this.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Experience
Schools protect children from scary things like poison ivy and insects, and thus cancel most outdoor learning opportunities. Schools forbid teaching from having plants, animals (of all kinds) and soil in the classroom. Schools reinforce cultural fears of the natural world by forbidding any food that was not processed and wrapped in an industrial setting. Let's send the little tykes off to school wrapped in bubble wrap and, for Pete's sake, don't let them run at recess - they could skin a knee!
Dissections are being replaced with virtual frogs... because, of course, all frogs are two-dimensional, color-coded, there is no individual variation in organs, and textures/structures are not relevant. People are worried about frog rights (there are some relevant points here, but the experience cannot be satisfactorily simulated). People think that kids with dissecting scissors are dangerous (how old does a kid need to be to handle a knife? When did you get one?).
My son learned about how seeds grow into plants by... coloring then cutting out pictures of seeds, sprouts, plants, flowers, fruits, and harvest - then pasting them in order. That, because, I guess planting a seed and watching is too hard?
There are lots of experiences that schools are skipping that go beyond using exploration. And, these reductions take many guises. But, ultimately, like you did - kids learn by getting dirty, getting into something, and sometimes breaking stuff, needing a band-aid, or getting poison ivy. Our kids may be safer... but, they are bored and getting dumber. Fun is not the opposite of learning. Self-directed exploration is more useful than a month of worksheets.
In a few years, perhaps we can expect medical schools to abandon using cadavers in lieu of virtual people. Forestry agents can look at leaves online. Teachers can practice in virtual classrooms. Nurses can practice on robotic patients. Funny? Guess which ones of these are already happening.
Friday, August 26, 2011
Get a good workout - for your brain.
Likewise, if you ask too much of a gym workout - you either won't succeed (you can't lift the whole stack without working up to it). Alternatively, you may finish it but be too sore to follow through and go back to the gym the next time.
It seems to me that learning is the same process. So, it shouldn't surprise us that to make gains in learning and understanding new ideas (algebra, for example)... we should feel like we are struggling a little. Wrapping our minds around something new doesn't come easily. So, if you aren't feeling like you are struggling a bit - you probably aren't making gains. Obviously, if you can march through your schoolwork without really paying attention to it - it is too easy and you won't make gains. Similarly, if it is too hard - you won't be able to struggle to the answer - no gains again. Thus, one real key to education seems to be finding the "sweet spot", just the right level of difficulty.
Another key to education, which can be very difficult to develop, is a willingness to struggle. We intuitively want things to come easy and make us feel smart. But, to really figure something out, some degree of struggle seems to be necessary. If we frustrate too easily, we will miss these new insights.
Monday, August 8, 2011
What does handicapped mean?
Issues are not restricted to the old-folks home.
Whether it is a bum knee, hearing loss, digestion issues, eyesight degradation, memory loss, attentional deficits, social deficits, dysgraphia, dyslexia, or some other deficit - everyone has their issues. No one is perfect.
I read an inspirational post at freerangekids.com this morning that shows a handicapped boy wheeling himself to camp. The other parents are horrified that this poor child has to wheel himself with his friends down the road to camp. The kid's friends had to get their bikes to keep up with his speed-demon wheeling. Which kids are handicapped? It is the ones that aren't allowed to walk on their own or the ones that are forced to?
Early on in my teaching career, I had a student that was "handicapped". In that I teach field courses with some rigorous physical activities, early in the semester I pulled him aside.
"I see that you have issues with your arm. You look very capable. I just want to let you know that if you are ever asked to do something that is difficult or challenging - just give me a nod, and I will understand. Do you have any specific limitations that I should know about?"
"Nope. I'll be fine."
Boy, was he ever serious. This one-handed boy toted canoes, paddled canoes, pulled nets, went through samples, shoveled, and did everything everyone else did - plus some. What a great kid. This kid hadn't accomplished a lot despite his disability - his disability gave him the fire to accomplish whatever he wanted to. How did he do it? I couldn't even tell you... I saw the kid tote a canoe and paddle it, and I am still not sure how one paddles one-handed. He's an accomplished fisherman too!
High school football? Sure - he played until his father didnt' allow him to - after his good arm was shattered in a particularly rough tackle. I knew him after he'd recovered from his football injury. This kid was a perfectly normal, if motivated, bright, and active young man.
No one ever told this kid what he couldn't do - so, he found a way to do whatever was thrown his way.
If we are defined by our actions rather than our words or our shortcomings... we need to take whichever issues life throws at us, however big or small, and succeed however it takes and however we define it.
Friday, June 24, 2011
To thine own self be true.
"To thine own self be true."
Polonius may well have meant by this to have your actions consistent with what he considered to be good character - represent yourself well by your actions. Today, we extend this expression to include that one's actions should be consistent with one's ideals, beliefs, and thoughts - that we may know the person by their actions, deeds, and expressions.
This is so important to live. People are happier, more comfortable in their own skins, self-assured, when they behave like the people they are. This is the kind of message that we impart to children (our own, our children's friends, and in my case - also my students).
Our children should let their actions and words reflect themselves - and the best of themselves. This can be a self-check to insure that they are keeping their thoughts, minds, and deeds healthy and compassionate. If you wouldn't say it or do it in front of your grandmother - you shouldn't say it or do it.
We need, however, to be aware of what this expression means to a broad diversity of people.
I attended a meeting last week... there was a young man there who was worried. He was moving to a foreign country and he was worried about how he would be perceived. What if he wanted to date someone local, would it be legal? Could he just be himself there? Would he need to worry about being arrested? Should he lie about who he is?
As a married, middle-aged mom - I don't have tothink about this; I can give my husband a kiss in public, hold hands, and share an intimate moment on date night. But, in our ultra-religious community, if I were gay - whether I could express myself safely would be a constant theme in my life. To whom can I be honest without worrying about repercussions for myself, my children, my partner, my job...
We need, as compassionate people, to find a way to let people be true to their own selves. As long as everyone involved in any relationship is consenting (and able to consent) - no one else need worry or even think about what dynamics are involved.
If you never have - attend a PFLAG meeting, it may open your eyes.
http://community.pflag.org/
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Math phobia - it's contagious.
I didn't just decide to vilify other teachers overnight. This notion has grown over a decade of observing teachers. I've watched lots of teachers... daycare teachers, elementary education teachers, elementary education counselors, high school teachers, other college professors, and teachers of teachers (college education professors). Over and over, I see the same behavior, hear the same concerns, and when students here these words over and over - they learn that this approach is acceptable, normal, and correct.
"I hate math". "I can't do math". "When I heard that there was math involved, I quit". "Math is too hard for me". This is what I keep hearing teachers say. Sometimes, I have heard this in front of students. Sometimes, it is just the attitude that they carry into the classroom.
If kids hear that math is scary, bad, difficult, and not worthy of working hard to learn - what do you suppose that they learn?
At a recent teaching conference, for college professors, a math professor used a mathematical concept as the grist for examining a new teaching method. They chose an easy topic, so that we could focus on how the method works. The concept that we covered (just as grist for exploring a teaching method), was learning the characteristics of the following quadrilaterals: rhombus, parallelogram, square, rectangle, and trapezoid. I was gobsmacked - the math fear evoked by learning (oooooh) SHAPES had some college professors ready to walk out. Other college professors laughed in their seats that, "I don't do math", and they listened, but didn't participate.
If a generation of college professors finds it amusing, acceptable, and even funny that they can't describe four-sided shapes - no wonder our math teaching is going to hell in a handbasket.
Folks - I get it, you found math intimidating. But, as teachers, you have a responsibility to approach learning as fun exercise. You will never find me telling my students that I don't do english, I don't do writing, I don't do art, music, or whatever. I certainly recognize my weaknesses - but, like fine music - even if I can't make it - I should be able to appreciate it when I hear it.
Monday, May 23, 2011
There is no replacement for experience.
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Losing ourselves in connectivity
Saturday, May 14, 2011
No fun allowed, this is school.
The kids were so excited and loved to be told to "get your hands in there, you're here to get muddy". My son's teacher, as always, scolded kids that got too excited to wait their turn, yelled at the kids that couldn't wait for an invitation and stepped (in their boots) into the stream), and looked generally aggravated. After a few moments, I gently reminded her that she could relax today - this is my classroom. And she did.
But, when the kids were all actively engaged in digging through the net and I stood back for a moment - she leaned over and said - "you know, they're all just having fun now". Apparently, she viewed that as a bad thing. She viewed having fun as being mutually exclusive from learning. She didn't see that by tying their activities back to the opening lesson - tying the message back to the mud-picking (that was giggle inducing)... they could learn and have fun.
And, that, my friends is one of the problems with education today. Learning is fun for kids until they learn it isn't. Kids are like little sponges that love to learn - until we make the process drudgery. Is it always fun? No. But, we can balance the rote exercises with active learning (and mud) to keep more kids engaged.
This, by the way, is the same teacher that blanched when I picked up a spider to share, and goggled as I taught a child how to pick up a crayfish - because I told the kid how to do it. I had the confidence that this seven-year-old could do it. Then, I told the kid that "you can't whine if you get pinched, though, you're picking it up, it's not like it's chasing you". The kid picked up the crayfish (properly), and smiled broadly enough to light up the day. That is a lesson the kid will remember.
The other fun thing - while one day soon, my son will realize that I am old (and by defintion, then) uncool. For one day, my son and his friends thought that I am the coolest mom around, with the coolest job. Even some of the other parents said so.
Wednesday, May 11, 2011
I like people, really I do.
Further, although I like the idea of going to a large party... in practice, I find that I feel lost in large social settings. I get overwhelmed and have a difficult time following conversation. My favorite party would be a gathering of four to eight people where we can talk and chat. This is why I love to invite a handful of folks over at a time to shoot pool. We are lousy pool players, but with the distraction of the pool game to follow and a not-overwhelming number of people - I can really have a terrific time.
Similarly, I found a perfect job for my predisposition. As a college professor, I spend 12 hours a week in a classroom, enjoying interacting with students (and, I really enjoy it). But, I enjoy it because I spend most of the rest of my time in my office. In my office, I am either alone or working with one or two people at a time - just right for me. At other times that I can choose, I can socialize with my colleagues over lunch or in the hall, and then return to my office to recharge.
I've always been this way - navigating public school as a child was horrific. If I hadn't been a bit of an outcast already, my inability to cope with the constant flow of people (from a crowded classroom, through crowded, chaotic halls to the next classroom) would have made me one. About 25% of people identify themselves as introverts. This really just means that they find time with people tiring and time alone revitalizing. Imagine, you extroverts out there, how you'd feel if a mandatory part of your upbringing required you to be by yourself in a room for six straight hours every day? Yeah, I thought so.
This is one of many ways that public education fails children. I would surmise (speculation only) that many (if not most) of the 25% of our population that identifies themselves as introverts find the straight six hours of public school exhausting. Like my oldest son, when he was in public school (and me, as a child) - many children get off the schoolbus at the end of the day completely wiped out. Z used to get off the bus to spend the next forty-five minutes in the bathroom. He didn't need the bathroom - he needed a quiet and private place to decompress.
This is one way that homeschooling can accomodate needs that the public school cannot. Z is happy and outgoing when he sees people now. As he no longer faces a barrage of people all day long; when he has time to socialize, he is eager to do so. He can choose to spend times with appropriately sized groups of people (generally small). He can spend time with the people that make him feel better about himself and avoid trying to navigate the complex and strange social world that we call public school. He is happier and does better with his friends in doses than he did when in a classroom all day, every day.
Some might say that lack of socialization is a problem for homeschooled kids. Bah. If the social experiences in school mimicked adult life - that would be a scary thing. In adult life, if you choose your profession well - mean girls, bullies, playground antics, and sophomoric put-downs are not part of being appropriately socialized. Part of the problem with those that believe this myth of homeschool is that teachers and psychologists, therapists and school administrators are almost exclusively extroverted and have a difficult time understanding the challenges that schools present to introverts. Further, they think that all introverts are shy - we are not. All introverts find socializing tiring - but we socialize in different ways: some by trying to control social situations, some by chatting incessantly, some by silence, some by sneering... we are all different. I only wish that I could return to my awkward kid self and reinforce that being introverted and enjoying your own company is perfectly ok. While being popular is commonly expressed as a suitable goal - would make you unhappy. Popularity is partly characterized by (hello, duh) being around other people most of the time, often in large groups.
I will take this one step further and suggest that, at the very least, while it is unrealistic to expect schools to provide private time to introverted kids - they could reinforce that it is ok, normal, and provide some better coping mechanisms for children that don't understand why school leaves them mentally exhausted. If you got here because you need this kind of reassurance - you're ok. There are jobs out there for you that can balance your (everyone's) need for social interaction with time to yourself. There are romantic partners that also can balance your need for companionship and understand your need to have time to yourself.
There are resources that understand you - here is just one, there are many more: http://introvertzone.com/
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Choosing kids for my class.
- When someone is having a bad day, they are told to regain their focus and let it go during the class - just like you have to in life when your dog just died and you still need to go to work.
- When someone is discouraged because something comes easier to other people; they are told to look straight ahead. "You are only competing against your previous best".
- They are reminded that rocking out the stuff that comes easy to you doesn't test their mettle nearly as much as trying their best at the stuff that comes hardest to them.
- They find that, whatever it is that you are learning, it will come easier to some people than to others. If it is harder for you - you just have to put in the extra effort.
- They find that sometimes the right move, done perfectly, doesn't have the intended consequence. You just have to figure it out from there.
- There is no shortcut around putting in the time and effort.
Here are the kids that need this Sensei the most:
- The boy that doesn't believe that he can succeed.
- The girl that doesn't know how to carry herself in social setttings.
- The boy that doesn't participate in sports because he isn't confident in his abilities.
- The girl that doesn't like her body.
- The boy that doesn't know what to do when someone picks on him.
- The girl that doesn't believe she can succeed in something if she doesn't get it the first time.
- The boy that doesn't connect with his friends except through videogames.
- All of the kids that are easily distracted, unsure of themselves, don't believe in their own power to make decisions, don't value their personal achievements, measure only their failures, and find it hard to value themselves.
I have seen children like these attend this class and slowly find their way to stand up taller. They cry less when they are sparring. They sometimes (even if it isn't always) dust themselves off and fight back when sparring. They find that with time they can do things they thought impossible. They learn that leverage is more important than brute strength (and, if that isn't a metaphor for life, I don't know what is). They find that hard work sometimes does pay off, and they might learn to value themselves.
As a teacher myself, it is really easy sometimes (especially on a frustrating day) to gravitate toward wanting to teach the "A" students. They are receptive, positive, and they get it. But, they would have learned it if a monkey taught them. They might like me and be responsive - but, they don't need me. The kids that need me are the ones whose lives I might change. They can be frustrating. They can be difficult. They can make you stay awake at night - wishing that you teach only the best-of-the-best. But, when you teach the students that need you most, sometimes one of them becomes something that they didn't believe they could. My son will probably never be a top-notch black belt. (But, who knows, anything is possible with enough grit, and he is learning to find that.) What he is learning is to believe in himself. If you truly believe in teaching, you aren't in it to make more people just like you; you are in it to make more people that find the worth in themselves. Whatever that worth is.Friday, May 14, 2010
On the Precipice
Beautiful, gentle, introspective Z is having a difficult time in school. Don't get me wrong, he loves to learn, and reads constantly (I catch mysefl saying things like: "Put the book down and eat"). We have struggled for three years now trying to get him what he needs in the system. He scores exceedingly well on tests, aces work that interests him, and can't start work that he finds dull. He gets caught surrepticiously reading when he should be doing worksheets. When asked to do a little open-ended project, he imagines this great ambitious project - too complex to really complete, then gets lost in implementation.
His teachers have trouble trying to help him. His primary teacher this year clearly thinks he is being lazy. We've tried to point out that, if he had dyslexia, she'd help him read. Helping a child with attentional issues get organized and start is the same thing. She is not a believer.
The school refuses to formally identify his needs or put an IEP in place. He is gifted, does well on tests, aces the work he does hand in - what's the problem? Except, he only hands in a fraction of the work, much of that done at home with our nagging, cajoling, and surrendering positive family time to get it done.
So, while working full-time in a college, and doing everything else, I am planning to (probably?) homeschool/unschool him next year in a corner of my office.
Am I insane?
My planned curriculum is to let him do what he loves most (learn and read, about anything and everything), do some structured math stuff, write both creatively (comic book, maybe) and reflectively (a journal reflecting on his readings), and explore.
Will this work?
This great, gaping hole stands in front of us, for me to help him fill.
Teaching Good Sportsmanship.
Winning the tournament is not our goal for B. Frankly, in first grade, it would probably be unrealistic. We want him to love the game, flex his brain muscles a bit, and have some fun. Every week, before the tournament, we review our goals: Play as smart as you can. Be kind to your opponent. Be gracious regardless of the outcome - you are there for fun.
The tournament is run by the teacher assigned to the Talented and Gifted Program (TAG). It is a somewhat ironic placement because, while she is really enthusiastic, she isn't so much "gifted". As such, the TAG program is notorious for being "more" stuff, rather than "more interesting" stuff for the TAG kids. This is what we've experienced with Z in the program and one of many reasons we are on the verge of homeschooling Z next year.
The TAG teacher was unable to figure out how to run a double elimination round-robin. So, J made a diagram for her showing how the brackets work. She thought that was too complicated and couldn't understand the winner and loser brackets, so decided on a double-elimination point system instead. Two losses and your out, but the point leader still standing at the end takes all. A reasonable alternative.
At six-years-old and in first grade, B is having a great run. The first week, he played a disappointed third grader that wanted to play someone older, so she would be "challenged" - B beat her. The second week, he faced a fifth-grader. This fifth-grader was cocky about facing a first grader at the start of the game - and started trash talking. B hasn't ever really heard "trash-talk" before. Then, when B started to gain the advantage, the fifth-grader (let's call him Joe) started trying to cajole B into making foolish moves: "you don't want to do that", "watch out, probably not a good idea", "oh, yeah - move that one". Finally, B was getting flustered, so J pointed out to him that he should play his own game and not let someone else manipulate him. A few moves later, B won by check-mate. J explained the circumstance to the TAG teacher, and mentioned that she really needs to talk to Joe about table talk, because it is really not allowed in chess.
Joe went to his mom (a teacher in the school) to complain that B's dad helped B win. Joe's mom went to the TAG teacher to complain. TAG teacher says "Oh, I'll talk to him about not helping his child". TAG teacher did not point out that Joe's behavior was unsportsmanlike. Then, she relented and while B kept the points for the win, she gave Joe a bye for the game that he lost. This solution is not great, but perhaps reasonable in that J did speak to B during the game. This would have been fine if accompanied by some sincere messages about fair play and honor.
But, it doesn't end there. The bitching has continued, Joe's mom has continued her relentles complaining that Joe was unfairly beaten due to J's assistance. So, this morning, the teacher announced that she has given both Joe and B wins for the game.
Since then, B has defeated a third grader and another fifth-grader, both by check-mate. B is tied for first in the tournament - with Joe.
This leaves me with so many questions:
- Do we wonder why Americans have a reputation for bad sportsmanship and whining?
- What kind of message does this send to children about honor and sportsmanship?
- How can we still respect this teacher for not (at least) making a point about fair play?
- Will B still like chess after this?
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
Welcome to my neglected home.
If you are here as a regular visitor - you can see me rant over at stophomework.com today on Obama's initiative to increase the duration of both school years and days. Because, if something isn't working - what you need is MORE OF IT.
Eesh.
Tuesday, June 9, 2009
Welcome
Have a look around at my often-neglected little blog.
If you are a "local", I am a guest author for today's post at stop homework, check it out.
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Shouting, crying, rolling on the floor - full out tantrum.
I commented last week on StopHomework.com. Sarah, the owner of that blog, asked if I might guest post - and I'm working on it, I promise.
http://stophomework.com/a-college-professor-speaks-out/1265
Here is my problem: My philosophical problems with homework, both in general and in its usual implementation are all over the place.
I want to write:
- how education is screwing our children out of opportunities to be creative and innovative, I've already touched on that here.
- how ridiculous and wrong it is for our schools to simultaneously bemoan the obesity epidemic in the USA while having our kids sit behind desks plugging away at worksheets for six hours every day then sending them home with more work to do in lieu of playing outside.
- how traditional school assignments that spell out every last detail of the assignment (except for actually doing it for the kid) paralyze student's ability to create, modify, and respond to assignments that require critical thinking, judgment, and innovation.
- how appalled I am at how little outdoor exploration is included in education. Understanding the resources we rely upon and the world around us should be integral to our education. Short "nature walks" where we point at stuff is not a replacement for getting dirty, discovering wild nettles, poison ivy, ants, and other creepy crawlies. To further explore this, read Louv's "Last Child in the Woods" - he is far more eloquent than I am.
- how, under the guise of safety, we are restricting any independent exploration of children. To grow healthy and responsible, kids need to learn to be responsible for themselves (in appropriate doses and with instruction - of course). I regularly see college students that literally panic in situtations that require a little trouble-shooting (vans break down on college trip, airline delays, illness during test period, regular bumps and bruises, scary flying insects outside, etc.). Sometimes, I think that the most valuable thing my students learn on field trips is how to deal with everyday life-time nuisances without calling Daddy on their cell phones.
- why it is that teachers feel compelled to send some work home, whether or not it will provide a valuable learning opportunity.
- how my philosophy of giving assignments in the classroom has changed since I have seriously considered exactly what it will take to satisfy my demand and what they are expected to get out of the exercise. That is, be willing to either actually do (I have done this), or imagine doing the assignment yourself. That may change the amount or type of assignments that you require.
- how my philosophy of work has changed toward empowering students to make choices. Where possible, the students (all together) select assignment due dates, pick between possible assignments, or select readings (from a list of appropriate ones). It makes a task less onerous if students have been empowered to make choices.
- when we will include allowing children to learn independence in the list of educational goals, even if that requires sometimes letting kids make mistakes. When I was a kid (yes, I walked uphill, both ways) I took a chemistry class where we played with fire, threw sodium into water (it was FUN), made chlorine gas. In biology, we used scalpels to dissect animals, and grew E. coli. We went fishing for the fishing club. And, all of these experiences were in sixth grade! I was
allowedempowered to be an indpendent person from an early age, with the caveat that being responsible went with the independence. So many of my college students simply don't know how to accept responsibility for their own actions, which also means that they can't fully appreciate their accomplishments either (how sad).
In answer to your burning question: I decided that I've already passed second grade - I don't need to worry about second grade homework. Does Yale University reject incoming students because they didn't write about Egypt in second grade?
I told Z, "Do it or don't do it. If you don't, you will fail the assignment and that would be your problem. Also, if you don't finish it you won't get to read tonight in bed (reading is his absolute favorite thing in life). But, it is up to you."
Then, I told him to ask for assistance if he needs it, but I'm going outside with B (younger brother).
He thought about it for awhile, then he did his homework.
And, my head didn't explode. What a mess that would have been!
